top of page
Search

The Question I Have Been Asked for 40 Years

roxburytims6
Nov 9
5 min read

A personal reflection on what investors actually want, and what I spent a career trying to build for them.


I want to start with something honest.


When I began in this industry in the 1980s, I believed, genuinely believed, that the job of a financial advisor was to find the best managers, allocate across the right asset classes, and trust the system. I spent years doing exactly that. I built a firm. I grew. I learned. And slowly, over a very long time, I started to notice something that bothered me.


Almost nobody was getting what they actually wanted.


What Investors Have Always Told Me They Want


I have sat across from thousands of clients over four decades. Some had a few hundred thousand dollars. Some had hundreds of millions. A family office in Dubai. A retired teacher in New Jersey. An entertainment executive who came into sudden wealth and had no idea what to do with it.


The words were different every time. But what they were describing was almost always the same two things.


They wanted their money to grow. And they wanted to not lose it when things went wrong.

That sounds simple. And every advisor I have ever met, including my younger self, would respond with some version of the same speech: that you cannot have both. That growth requires risk. That risk means accepting losses. That this is just the nature of markets, and the sooner you make peace with it, the better.


I said that for years. I believed it.


I am not sure I believe it anymore.


The Moment Things Started to Shift


It was not one single moment, honestly. It was more like a long, slow accumulation of discomfort.


I watched active managers underperform their own benchmarks year after year. Not all of them, not always, but enough to make me question whether the whole premise was sound. I watched small cap investing get hollowed out as private equity and venture capital scooped up the most promising companies before they ever reached public markets. I watched international allocations drag on portfolios for a decade while US large cap technology ran circles around everything else.


At some point I had to ask myself: what actually works?


The honest answer, based on what I had seen, was index investing. Wide exposure, low cost, market-level results by definition. Not exciting. But real.


The problem was that index investing still left the second half of what my clients wanted completely unaddressed. They were still riding the market all the way down every time it fell. A 40% drop in the S&P 500 meant a 40% drop in their portfolio. That 1:1 relationship between upside and downside had not changed at all.


What I Found When I Started Pulling Things Apart


I have been interested in options since I was literally in college. The mechanics of them, how they price, how they behave, have always fascinated me. So when I started encountering structured products, I did not just accept them at face value. I wanted to understand exactly how the outcomes were being achieved.


What I found was, in hindsight, obvious. The results were coming from a combination of fixed income and options working together. Fixed income generating yield. That yield being deployed into options contracts. The contracts defining what happens on the upside and what happens on the downside. The whole position evaluated at expiration, not day to day.


Once I saw that clearly, something clicked. The big banks were taking this concept and packaging it into structured notes with caps on the upside and their own credit risk baked in. There was a spread being taken. There were limitations being built in. The investor was getting something, but not the full version of what was possible.


I started asking a different question. What would it look like to build this kind of position directly, using individual securities held in the client's own account, without the bank in the middle?


What I Have Observed Over Time


I want to be careful here, because I am not in the business of making promises or telling anyone what to do with their money. What I can share is what I have personally observed over years of building and monitoring these positions.


I have seen positions on the S&P 500 that were structured to capture market gains at a multiple, where the downside was substantially reduced compared to simply owning the index. I have seen a position structured to achieve one level of upside actually deliver more, because the underlying math played out better than the projections at the time of construction.


I have seen what happens in a down market, when an investor who owned a traditionally structured position sat with full losses, while someone in a position built with protective elements experienced something very different. Not zero loss, in many cases. But a fraction of what the market delivered.


I have also seen positions not perform as expected. I have seen interest rate environments that compressed what was achievable. I have seen volatility conditions that made certain structures less favorable. This is not a magic solution. It is a set of tools, and like any tools, the results depend on how they are used and what conditions they are used in.


What I have never seen, in all of this, is a client who, after understanding how these positions work and what they are designed to do, went back to wanting the 1:1 approach.


Why I Wrote a Book About It


Last year, I put together a book called Risk Management in Stock Market Investing: An Advanced Approach. It ended up as a number one hot seller on Amazon in the derivatives investing category, which honestly surprised me.


I wrote it because I kept having the same conversation over and over. Someone would sit across from me, hear the explanation of how a structured position works, and say something like: why has no one told me about this before?


The book was my attempt to answer that question at scale. To lay out the mechanics clearly, without the sales pitch, without the fund structure wrapped around it. Just the underlying logic, explained plainly.


If you are curious, it is available on Amazon. I will put the link below.


A book cover with the title reading "Risk Management in Stock Market Investing: Lowering Principal Risk, An Advanced Approach." Authored by Timothy L. Smith, CFP, Founder of Structured Portfolios. the background of the text is a Florida waterfront city skyline with a blue sky.


A Note on Who This Is Relevant For


I work primarily with investors who have significant portfolios, typically in the range of five million dollars and up. That is not because the concept only works at that level, but because the mechanics of building these positions, the specific securities involved, the sizing, the monitoring, all of it makes more practical sense at that scale.


The people I work with are often family offices, foundations, institutions, and individuals who have reached a point in their financial lives where losing large amounts of capital is simply not something they are willing to do, but where sitting in cash or bonds is equally unacceptable. They want to participate. They just want to participate thoughtfully.


That tension is exactly what drew me to this work in the first place. And it is what keeps me here after 40 years.


This newsletter is for educational and informational purposes only. Nothing here constitutes investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past observations do not guarantee future results.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page